Compare
How it compares, including where it loses.
There are five other sensible ways to keep knowledge at hand when the network is down. Here is how each one does, by category, with no brand names.
Claims about a whole category say "typically", because individual products differ. Where an alternative is better, the table says so.
Comparison table
| What matters | Gridfall Library | PDFs on a USB stick | Wi-Fi hotspot box | Build it yourself | Printed binder | Phone apps that need a signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Works with no signal | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No. Typically little or nothing loads |
| Works with no battery | No. It needs a charged device; keep a power bank or small solar charger | No | No. Typically the box and your device both need power | No | Yes. This is where paper wins | No |
| One search across everything | Yes. Titles, chapters, articles and dictionary words | No. Typically no. You open files one at a time | Partly. Typically one collection at a time | Partly. Only if you build an index | No. A table of contents, if you made one | Partly. Typically yes, while you are online |
| A real app, not loose files | Yes. Reader, map and inventory in one place | No. Loose files and whatever viewers you have | Partly. Typically web pages served to your browser | Partly. Whatever you assemble | No. Paper | Partly. Typically a separate app for each job |
| Runs on the device in your hand, nothing else to power or connect | Yes | Yes, on a device with a USB port and file viewers | No. Typically you power the box, then join its Wi-Fi | Partly. Depends on what you build | Yes | Yes |
| Serves several devices at once | No. One card or drive, one device at a time | No | Yes. This is where a hotspot box wins | Partly. If you set up a server | Partly. One reader at a time; pages can be shared out | Yes, each on its own connection |
| Source, licence and checksum for every item | Yes. Every item has a provenance record | No. Typically no | No. Typically no | Partly. Only if you record it yourself | No. Typically no | No. Typically no |
| Offline map with GPS | Yes. Colorado edition: 22 layers and a Colorado street basemap | No. Static map files at best | Partly. Varies by product | Partly. If you find and prepare the map data | Partly. Paper maps; no GPS | Partly. Typically only areas you saved beforehand |
| Supply inventory with expiry reminders | Yes. Kits, days of water and food, shopping list | No | No. Typically no | Partly. A spreadsheet, if you keep one | Partly. A paper list, updated by hand | Partly. Separate apps, typically with an account |
| App updates | Partly. The app checks for updates and installs them when you tap Install | None. Files stay as you saved them | Partly. Varies by product | No. You redo the downloads yourself | No. Reprint | Yes. Typically automatic, while you are online |
| Time to get it working | Yes. Ready when it arrives | Partly. Hours of finding and saving files | Partly. Typically some setup | No. Typically days to weeks of downloading and sorting, plus licence homework | Partly. Printing, punching and filing | Yes. Minutes, while you are online |
| Account or sign-in | Yes. None. Nothing is tracked | Yes. None | Yes. Typically none | Yes. None | Yes. None | Partly. Typically an account, and often tracking |
| Cost | Partly. A one-time purchase with no subscription; price announced before orders open | Yes. The price of a USB stick | Partly. Varies by product | Yes. Free, if you have the time and skills | Yes. Paper and ink | Partly. Often free; some charge a subscription |
- Yes
- Partly, or it depends
- No
To be fair
Where the alternatives win
None of these is a bad choice. Several of them work well alongside the library.
A printed binder needs no battery at all. Keep printed basics too: your plan, key phone numbers, first aid steps and a paper map.
Building it yourself is free if you have the time and the skills, and you will know every file in it.
A Wi-Fi hotspot box can serve several devices at once, which suits a group sharing one library.
Phone apps are the best tool there is while the network is up. Keep using them.
The difference
What you get that the others typically leave out
- One search across everything, down to chapters, articles and dictionary words.
- A real app with a reader, a map and an inventory, not a folder of loose files.
- It runs on the device in your hand. There is nothing else to power up or connect to.
- A source, licence and checksum for every item, so you know what you are reading.
- An offline map with GPS in the Colorado edition.
- A supply inventory with expiry reminders and days of water and food worked out.
- App updates: the app checks for updates and installs them when you tap Install.
- No long downloads and no licence homework. It arrives loaded.
Straight talk
Who should not buy this
If one of these is you, something else will serve you better, and we would rather say so now.
You only have an iPhone or iPad.
Gridfall Library does not run on them. You would need an Android device or a Windows, Mac or Linux computer.
You want something that works with no power at all.
That is paper. Print the basics and keep them dry. The library needs a charged device.
You need detailed offline maps outside Colorado today.
Maps and local guides cover Colorado today. More states are in development. The reference library itself is useful anywhere.
You want training, or a guarantee.
This is a reference library. It does not replace a first aid course, professional care or practice, and it cannot promise an outcome.
You enjoy building and maintaining your own.
If you have the time and skills, doing it yourself is free and a good project. We would rather you be prepared than be our customer.
You need to share one library across a group at once.
A card or drive serves one device at a time. A hotspot box, or one of our products per household, fits that better.
Reserve yours
Decided it fits? Reserve one.
We will email you when orders open. Nothing to pay now.
Still weighing it up? The free kit checklist and water calculator are useful whatever you choose.